Writer: Ed Solomon, Boaz Yakin, Edward Ricourt
Starring: Jesse Eisenberg, Mark Ruffalo, Woody Harrelson, Isla Fisher, Dave Franco, Morgan Freeman, Michael Caine, Mélanie Laurent
Tomatometer: 47/26/75 (all critics, top critics, audience)
Spoiler-free Summary: Jesse, Woody, Isla, and Dave are all middling street magicians. A mysterious person in a Zuckerbergian hoodie recruits the four of them to perform as a team. After a year of preparation, the Four Horsemen open their act in Las Vegas. For their final trick of opening night, the group magically robs a bank, setting off an FBI-led manhunt and a slew of high-profile crimes.
Two Cents: Like many who saw its trailer, I could not wait for this movie. Boasting a stellar cast and the combination of a classic film genre (bank robbery) with another that has long been under-appreciated (magic), this movie had “summer fun” written all over it. Sadly, those words were written with one of these.
The first half of the movie is actually quite entertaining. Some of the tricks are extremely cool (keep telling yourself they’re not just cheap cinematography tricks), and the story moves with the pace of a Formula-1 car. However, the movie loses steam toward the end of Act II, as it turns into a game of “Who’s playing whom?”.
Let me be the first to diagnose director Leterrier with Shyamalonosis. Now You See Me is doomed by Leterrier’s obsession with forcing a shocking twist at the expense of the rest of his film. Like Shyamalan almost always does, Leterrier fails miserably in his quest, completely wasting a promising build-up and decent performances from Eisenberg, Harrelson, and Ruffalo. A twist only works when it is supported by that which comes before it, and this movie’s not-so-big twist could be easily debunked by any of the scenes that precedes it. That’s not a twist, it’s a lie. (Out of respect for those who have yet to see Now You See Me, I’ll refrain from saying anything that might be considered a spoiler.) M. Night would be proud of you, Louis, but he’s probably the only one. Even your own mother thinks you stink.
It was great to see Dave Franco in another big release. He had a respectable role in last year’s 21 Jump Street, but he has yet to reach the notoriety of his brother James. He is a gifted comedic actor, and I’m sure we’ll be seeing much more if him in the future. Isla Fisher must be an awesome person to count as a friend. She’s married to Sacha Baron Cohen, and she seems to be a ton of fun. However, even with the world’s greatest push-up bra, she’s completely wasted in this movie. She’s not a great actress, but she can be entertaining and funny when given the opportunity. Morgan Freeman and Michael Caine should have saved on airfare and sent cardboard cutouts of themselves to the set. They could not have seemed more uninterested in this movie. Mélanie Laurent (Shosanna from Inglourious Basterds) is pretty darn close to mesmerizing, but Leterrier did not get out of her what he could or should have.
Should I/Shouldn’t I: Don’t view the title of this movie as an obligation. Now You See Me (or, maybe, you don’t) is a fun movie, but it doesn’t nearly reach its potential. You won’t hate it, but you’ll most likely be disappointed. With so many blockbusters coming out this summer, you’d be better off letting this one slip through the cracks and catching it on HBO next winter. If you forget to DVR it, feel free to save two hours and just ask me what happens at the end.
Sundae Rating: One scoop

